Open six days a week 000-000-0000
A clean stainless steel prep bench with a folded white cloth, a bench scraper and stacked steel mixing bowls

Straight talk

What we will not claim

Six sentences you will see advertised by bakeries and cafés, each quoted in full and answered with what is true of this kitchen instead.

  • Six claims, one page each
  • Four link to the rule they rest on

Some sentences cost a bakery nothing to print and are hard for anybody to check from the pavement. These six are common on bakery and café websites.

Each is quoted below as you might see it, and each has its own page: what is true instead, why the difference matters, and what to ask a real bakery.

Four of them rest on a rule — the city’s or the Food and Drug Administration’s — and those pages link to it. One is about how a bakery’s day actually runs. One is about this website.

None of this is modesty. A bakery that says exactly what it does — when a loaf was shaped, what the kitchen uses, how you pay — has given you something to hold it to.

What you will see advertised

Six claims, and the answer to each

What you will see advertised

“Health grade A. An A-rated bakery.”

Why There Is No Letter Grade on This Website

In New York City, bakeries and cafés are inspected by the Health Department and graded. The grade is printed on a serial-numbered card that the inspected business must post near its own entrance — the original card, not a photocopy. This bakery does not exist, has never been inspected, and has no grade, so this website shows none, and none of its photographs shows its entrance or a front window where a card would be.

Why

What you will see advertised

“Fully licensed and permitted. Permit number on file.”

A Permit Is Checked With the City, Not on a Website

A bakery café in New York City needs a food service establishment permit from the Health Department, whether its food is eaten at a table or carried out of the door — and a permitted business is inspected, with a record the city keeps under its name and address. A demonstration has no permit, so this site names none and prints no number.

Why

What you will see advertised

“Nut-free cakes. Allergy-safe bakery.”

Why We Cannot Promise Anything Is Nut-Free

Every recipe here is made in one kitchen where tree nuts are used every day. We can tell you that a recipe contains no nuts. We cannot tell you that anything we sell is free of them.

Why

What you will see advertised

“Gluten-free options available.”

Gluten-Free Has a Legal Definition We Cannot Meet

The Food and Drug Administration defines “gluten-free” for labelled food: it has to contain less than 20 parts per million of gluten. That rule binds packaged food, and the FDA recommends that restaurants and bakeries using the word on a menu mean the same thing. A bakery with flour in the air all day cannot promise that of anything, so we sell nothing described as gluten-free, “gluten-friendly” or “low gluten”.

Why

What you will see advertised

“Pay online and skip the line.”

Why You Pay at the Counter, Not on This Website

This website takes no payment of any kind — no card, no deposit, no account. You order online, and you pay at the counter when you collect.

Why

What you will see advertised

“Everything made fresh from scratch every morning.”

Baked Today Is Not the Same as Made Today

The bread and pastry on the shelves at opening was baked that morning — apart from the rye, which is baked the afternoon before because it slices better the next day, and the end shelf, which is the day before’s loaves and says so. Very little of it was made that morning: sourdough is shaped the afternoon before, croissant dough is laminated a day ahead, cake layers are baked a day or two before they are iced, and an almond croissant is a second-day croissant by recipe.

Why

Instead

Where this site describes what it does

Nobody bakes what is ordered here. This is a demonstration website. Woodside Bakehouse & Café is not a real bakery, nobody answers the telephone number on this site, and no order placed here is baked, packed or kept for anybody — even though the order form works and sends a real confirmation e-mail. Nothing is charged, because nothing on this site takes payment. If you need bread or a cake for a real occasion, please order it from a real bakery.

What we will do

Tell you what is in any recipe, hold your order until closing on its pickup day, and take payment at the counter when you collect.