Open six days a week 000-000-0000
A round vanilla layer cake cut into even wedges, two slices pulled out to show the layers, beside a cake server and small white plates

The journal

How Big a Cake Do You Need?

What a party slice is, why a cake cut from the middle feeds fewer, and how to choose between six, eight and ten inches.

Three sizes, and what the ranges mean

The menu describes our celebration cakes in one line: “Three-layer cakes in four flavours and three sizes, to order, with a short message if you want one.” Every one of them is about 5 inches tall, so the sizes differ across the top and not in height: 6-inch, 8-inch or 10-inch.

Servings are party slices — a finger’s width at the rim and about four inches tall — cut from the centre outwards. Cut wedges from the middle of a big cake and it will feed noticeably fewer.
SizeParty slicesPrice
6-incheight to ten$54.00
8-inchfourteen to eighteen$74.00
10-inchtwenty-four to thirty$98.00

Each size is sold for a range of people rather than a single number, and the knife decides where in that range your party lands. The ranges assume one particular cut, and it is worth knowing what it is before you choose.

What a party slice is

The small print under that table is the most useful sentence on the page. A party slice is a finger’s width at the rim and about four inches tall, cut from the centre outwards. That sounds narrow until you remember the height of the cake: every slice carries every layer.

The same note carries the warning that matters most: “Cut wedges from the middle of a big cake and it will feed noticeably fewer.” The ranges above are what a cake serves when it is cut the way the note describes, and not otherwise.

Party slices, wedding slices and the slice a ten-year-old expects

Cakes are counted in more than one unit, and a number in one unit is not a number in another. Wedding slices are a separate convention, and so is whatever a family has always cut at home. Every figure on this site is a party slice, as described above, and nothing else — so when you compare our sizes with a serving count anywhere else, check which slice that number means.

The third unit has no name, and at a children’s birthday it is the one that counts. A ten-year-old expects a wedge from the middle, which is exactly the cut the serving note warns about. For a table of children, plan from the low end of each range rather than the high one.

A worked example: a tenth birthday

One of the example orders on this site is a birthday, and it is worth reading for what sits beside the cake.

A tenth birthday

Ordered on Wednesday morning, collected Friday at 4:30pm

What is in the order

  • 1 × Dark chocolate cake, 8-inch
    Serves fourteen to eighteen — $74.00 each
    $74.00
  • 12 × Brown butter chocolate chip cookie
    One cookie — $4.25 each
    $51.00
  • Total to pay at the counter $125.00

The cake needs two days’ notice, so Friday is the earliest this order can be collected.

The cake is the 8-inch, which serves fourteen to eighteen in party slices. The twelve brown butter chocolate chip cookies are the margin: a tenth birthday is where wedges get cut, and a cookie does not depend on the knife.

The flavour is dark chocolate, which the flavour notes describe as “the cake most children ask for, and the one that travels best on a hot day.” And the timing follows the notice rule: ordered on Wednesday morning, collected Friday at 4:30pm, because the cake needs two days’ notice counted in days the ovens are on.

When the party is bigger than the biggest cake

The 10-inch cake serves twenty-four to thirty. Past that, order two: one order can take up to two of any one cake, and two cakes in two flavours solve a second problem at the same time. The flavour notes call lemon “sharp rather than sweet — the adult birthday”. Put it beside the chocolate, and a party of children and parents has a cake each.

One flavour needs a word of its own before it goes on a table of children: carrot and walnut. “It contains walnuts. It is also iced on the same bench as every other cake.” That second sentence is true of every cake here, whichever flavour you choose, and it is the reason no cake on this site is promised free of nuts.

Or add a tray. A cookie and brownie tray, twenty-four pieces, at $60.00, serves about twelve, with one day’s notice.

When the party is small

At the other end, even the 6-inch cake serves eight to ten, and that may be more cake than a small table wants. A slice of layer cake is $7.50: one of the four celebration cake flavours, cut at the counter; ask which is on today. It needs no notice.

Order it in time

Whatever the size, a cake needs two days’ notice, and a message on top can run to thirty characters. If the message matters, vanilla bean and raspberry is the one that suits a message in a coloured buttercream best, because the ground is pale. What can and cannot be piped is on the page about writing on a cake.

And if the day goes wrong and nobody reaches the counter in time, the cake is not lost. An order is held until closing on its pickup day. After that, bread and pastries go to the end shelf with the day’s other unsold bake, and a cake is kept in the cold room until the next opening.

Raspberries, blackberries and a few small flowers resting on smooth ivory buttercream
Fruit on buttercream: how the cakes on this site are finished, with the top left plain.

What needs notice. Celebration cakes need two days’ notice and catering trays and large bread orders need one, counted in days we are baking — Sunday, when the ovens are cold, does not count. An order placed after 3pm counts its notice from the next day, because that evening’s bake has already been planned.

Changing your mind. You can cancel from the link in your confirmation e-mail. An order with a cake, a tray or a large bread order can be cancelled until 6pm the day before pickup — after that it is already being baked. Anything else can be cancelled until its pickup window starts.

More from the journal

One kitchen, six allergens in the air. Everything here is made in one kitchen where wheat, sesame, tree nuts, eggs, milk and soy are used every day. We can tell you what is in a recipe; we cannot promise that any item is free of any allergen. If an allergy is serious, please do not rely on a label here — ask us, and consider a bakery with a dedicated kitchen.

The journal

Choose a size and a flavour

Every cake needs two days’ notice and is paid for at the counter when you collect it.